site/header2.jpg
ANTE UP: The Collection of Robert Eisenstadt

We welcome you to take part in Ante Up, the auction of the Robert Eisenstadt's incredible collection. The auction takes place on January 30, 2021 at 10:00AM CT. You can visit the auction website by clicking here.

You can also view the collection that is up for auction as a PDF.

If you have any questions about the auction, please contact Joseph Slabaugh (joeslabaugh@potterauctions.com, 773-472-1442) at Potter & Potter Auctions.

IN MEMORIAM: Robert Eisenstadt 1942 - 2020

On June 5, 2020, Robert Eisenstadt died peacefully at home, in the loving presence of his sister Nancy and his sister's family. He will be dearly missed by all of us who loved and appreciated him. If you would like to leave a story about Robert, write a message, or read what others have written, please click here.

He took pride in his collection and loved sharing it with fellow enthusiasts; please have a look and enjoy.

 

Robert Eisenstadt's
Antique Gambling Chips &  Gambling Memorabilia Web Site

Home Page: ordering info.,policies (satisfaction guaranteed, etc.), e-mail, etc.template.html
Site Map
My email address:  (removed email address)


1920s Carl Fisher's illegal Montauk Island Club
 
MontBldgChips0716.jpg

~ 5 chips for sale: new find/discovery ~
~ the only known chips from any old Long Island gambling place ~
~ special custom stylized club chip: "M" for Montauk Island Club ~
~ Philadelphia Enquirer:"one of the most ornately appointed gambling establishments
 in the East"~
~  Jazz Age-Roaring 20s summer colony for N.Y.'s rich and famous ~
~ $28 total (includes shipping) for set of 5 chips)~
~ *** read the background story below  *** ~
Montauk5.jpg


Table of Contents.  Links to the sections below:
1.  Carl Fisher -- developer of Montauk, Long Island, New York, and owner of the Montauk Island Club.
2.  Montauk Island Club, Star Island, Montauk, and Fisher's gambling business at Montauk.

3. Montauk, Long Island -- summer playground of the rich and famous.
4. Lake Montauk and Star island -- location of the Montauk Island Club.
5. 1929 Police raid on the Montauk Island Club.
6. Source and authentication of these "M" chips of the Montauk Island Club.


MapLtGulls072116.jpg


1.  Carl Fisher -- developer of Montauk, Long Island, New York, and owner of the Montauk Island Club.
CarlFisherr.jpg 
Carl Graham Fisher was the remarkable American entrepreneur  who rose from childhood poverty and a life-long battle against severe astigmatism to succeed at several businesses and run through several fortunes to finally develop Montauk, Long Island, NY.  �The history of modern Montauk is intimately interwoven with the impressive figure of one Carl Graham Fisher. In 1925, Fisher purchased the entire peninsula of Montauk -- over 10,000 acres in total -- to develop as a grand resort much of what makes up today's Montauk.  Its roads, churches, downtown village, harbor area, golf course, and dozens of commercial buildings and homes were built by Fisher during a whirlwind of development from 1926 - 32.�  One of his biggest projects was converting the lake, and small island inside the lake, to a salt sea lake and port (re-naming it Montauk Lake and Star Island, where his Casino was).

A gifted athlete, his interest in bicycle racing had led to his interest in bike clubs, bike racing and selling bicycles, then to automobiles and auto dealerships.  This led to him acquiring an interest in acetylene gas auto headlights, which he manufactured.  The headlights were eventually used on every auto in the country.   In 1917 he sold the business to Union Carbide, leaving Fisher with $6 million dollars. His auto interest led him to develop the Indianapolis Speedway, and �next, he organized and led the drive to build the first modern highway linking the East and West Coasts - the Lincoln Highway, and the North and South - the Dixie Highway.�

Next, �while vacationing in south Florida, he couldn't but help notice the barrier island that paralleled the city of Miami. Miami Beach, as it was called, was 3,500 acres of mangrove swamp and beach. Connected to the mainland by a half finished wooden bridge, it was unpopulated, and unwanted. Single handedly, Fisher transformed it into one of the most stylish resorts in the world.  He completed the bridge, cut down the mangroves, filled in the swamp, laid out the roads, and built magnificent hotels, homes and shops. It was a prodigious development, and brought him to the height of his fame and fortune.� He was now worth $50 million.

His next great challenge was Montauk.  �Three times the size of Miami Beach, almost entirely undeveloped, it was to be the culmination of his life's work. He bought all 10,000 acres in 1925 for the relatively modest sum of $2.5 million. He estimated it would take another $7 million to build it. "Miami in the Winter, Montauk in the Summer" was Fisher's slogan. He would provide the elite who had flocked to his Miami Beach with a comparably exclusive summer resort just hours from the social centers of New York and Newport.�  He "dreamed of a 'Miami of the North,' and to succeed he would need to construct a first class destination that offered the litany of activities the Astors, Vanderbilts, Goulds and others of that gilded time wished to pursue.�  Fisher's  "Montauk Manor [which still exists as a luxury resort today] was the most luxurious hotel on Long Island" (source).  It was the �Jazz Age� and the �Roaring 20s.�

�Fisher had planned for everything, everything that is except weather and the Great Depression. On September 17, 1926, a tremendous hurricane hit Miami Beach. � Then October 1929, the bottom fell out of the stock market, and real estate values began a dizzying fall. Then, the Great Depression in 1929.  Since much of Fisher's wealth was based on real estate, his fortune began to crumble. �. As his credit began to thin, Fisher sold his holdings -- the Speedway, Miami Beach hotels, homes, yachts, land nearly everything that could be liquidated. Stretched beyond even his formidable means, his empire collapsed into bankruptcy in 1932. Three years later, Fisher declared personal bankruptcy.�   He never completed his Montauk  dream.

Read more about him here, here, here, here, and here .
 
Incidentally, the Carl Fisher discussed here has no connection to the famous Fisher Auto Body company and large Fisher�s Island in Long Island Sound close to Connecticut.


2.  Montauk Island Club, Star Island, Montauk (also known as Star Island Casino), the place these chips were used during Prohibition. ...
Also: Fisher's gambling business at Montauk.
PIcIslandCasino.jpg
Carl Fisher's Montauk gambling club building, the source of these "M" gambling chips: 1928 photo of the Montauk Island Club. (source.)  It is has been said that Fisher was opposed to licensed gambling in Florida.  But he sure was in favor of illegal gambling at his Montauk Island Club, which he owned along with the entire Montauk peninsula from 1926 to 1932 when the project went into receivership.  Note, in section 5 below, the newspaper reports of the 1929 police raids against gambling at his  Montauk Island Club. On the internet I have found many sources that speak of his plans for gambling at Montauk, his ownership of the Montauk Island Club and his operational gambling club at Montauk Island Club (also known and written as the Star Island Casino or Island Club, since it was on Star Island in Montauk Lake):  here here  here here here .  Perhaps best: here  and here .

For some reason, the link that intermittently works is "404 page can not be found" sometimes, but I have a paper copy of the article: "Looking Back: The Story of the Casino in Montauk." It describes a swanky gambling place in Montauk, and then says, "If it sounds like Monte Carlo, it was meant to, but it is Montauk in the 1920s at the Star Island Casino (more often known as the "Montauk Island Club" as in the caption to the picture above) opened and constructed by the Montauk legend Carl Fisher.  It was located next door to the Montauk Yacht Club and near where the Star Island Marina is today ..., all on Star Island."
The article goes on describing how Mr. Fisher personally supervised the wine list and even the music.  It mentions Fisher losing control due to the Depression, and says a final police raid "closed down the operation permanently in the very late 1940s."  I'll mail a photocopy of the article to anyone who requests it.

Even after Fisher lost control of his Montauk properties, "the casino even continued to operate during the Depression ... until there was an embarrassing snafu. On Labor Day 1936, the casino was raided. One of the customers was New York Mayor Jimmy Walker. Thinking quickly as cops swarmed in, Mr. Walker put a white towel over his arm and walked about like a waiter, eventually slipping out the door. He took off his shoes and walked down the beach to the Montauk Yacht Club." (source .)

In Section 5, below, are newspaper accounts (NY Times, NY Herald Tribune, Philadelphia Inquirer) of police raids on the Montauk Island Club in the 1920s, during Fisher's reign there.

In Section 6, below, I go through the provenance of the chips (from the woman who lived near Montauk at the time).  And I explain how the chips are designed with an "M," not a "W."

Conclusion: these are "M" chips from the gambling Montauk Island Club (also known as the Star Island Casino and Island Club), but we can't say for certain whether they were used before or after  Carl Fisher's reign ended (or both times).  But they were used at the gambling casino on Star Island for the ponied New York City summer rich and famous of the 1920s and 30s.
'

3.  Montauk, Long Island -- summer playground of the rich and famous.
MontaukMapLtHse.jpg
New York's Long Island is 118 miles long, stretching from the New York City harbor in the west to landmark Montauk Point Lighthouse in the east.  The town of Montauk is about 15 miles from East Hampton, one of the tony ocean summer beach residences of New York's wealthy class.


4. Lake Montauk and Star island -- location of the Montauk Island Club.
Lake.jpg

Lake Montauk.  The lake (originally called Lake Wyandanch or the Great Lake) was a freshwater lake until 1927 when Carl Fisher blasted a hole on the northern shoreline to connect it to the open waters of the Atlantic Ocean. Before this, the Great Lake was the largest body of freshwater on Long Island, more than double the size of Lake Ronkonkoma.  Fisher did this because there was no safe mooring near Montauk for yachts to escape the Atlantic's rough weather.  Fisher's efforts were intended to use the lake as the port of his planned development to turn Montauk into the "Miami Beach of the North." On Star Island, the small island in the lake, he built the Montauk Yacht Club and the Montauk Island Club ( also known as the Star Island Casino). His other projects included Montauk Manor, Montauk Playhouse, Montauk Downs golf course, the six-story Montauk tower, etc. Fisher renamed the lake Lake Montauk.

Read about it here, and here.


5.  1929 Police raid on the Montauk Island Club.
MontaukRaids.jpg
Newspaper stories of the September 21, 1929, police raids on Fisher's Montauk casino.  Those mentioned in the news stories as named in the warrants were employees and front-men for Fisher.  Note how the story mentions that the "wealthy" patrons of the casino were from "South Hampton" and other Long Island "Summer colonies."  The Philadelphia Inquirer story says the casino is reputed to be one of the "most ornately appointed gambling establishments in the East."

The casino must have reopened, because I have a lengthy April 12, 1930, newspaper article, presumably form the NY Herald Tribune, in front of me entitled "Many Alluring Cruising Points Off R.I. Coast," that notes the "alluring charm of Lake Montauk" with its "polo fields, golf courses, casino [emphasis supplied], hotel, and ocean bathing."


6.  Source and authentication of these "M" chips of the Montauk Island Club.
MontaukUnderline.jpg
The helpful man who sold me these Montauk Island Club chips, at a modest price that I pass on to you, related to me how he acquired the chips.  He said, �My aunt Ann, sister of my father, was born, in Long Island City, in 1915 and died in 1977.  At 16, she was already moving with a fast crowd. She enjoyed fishing at Montauk and chatting with fellow fisherman Al Smith, the 1928 democratic presidential candidate. In the mid to late 30s, she married � an Italian gentleman who owned a barber shop in Patchogue, Long Island, which also fronted an active bookmaking business. � My aunt knew many people on both sides of the law. �. Ann's third and last husband was a horse trainer/owner, and they toured the smaller tracks from Cleveland to New Orleans to New England from the late forties through the early 70s. � My aunt gave my father, born 1918, the Montauk chips in the 1940s. She vividly recalled the guard house and "spotters" on the road, and the swankiness of the casino. � . I am 70 and first saw the chips in my father's possession in the 1950s. � I do not know if my aunt actually worked at the casino, but she was married to a Long Island bookie in the 1930s. My best guess is that she came into possession of the chips from someone in Montauk, a gambler;  or her husband; also, many items seized by the police eventually filtered out to friends, if not destroyed. � My personal certainty that the chips are from the Montauk Casino is 95%. Enjoy them in good health. �The casino apparently was next door to the Montauk Yacht Club. � �

From the picture above, I give one reason why I think the letter on the chips is "M," for Montauk, and not "W" for some place else.  The four AC chips are roulette chips from the old Agua Caliente Casino (the same age as the Montauk chips here, it so happens).  Note the underscore line under the "6" and "9" chips -- the line is to help determine how to hold the chip when reading the number or letter, that it is a six, not an upside-down 9, for example.  That it is an M, not a W.  I have not seen other letter chips in this style.  It looks like a custom logo for Montauk to me.


Click here for the Chip Guide entry.


Home Page: ordering info.,policies (satisfaction guaranteed, etc.), e-mail, etc.
Site Map 

� 2016 by Robert Eisenstadt
all rights reserved